An Allstate roof claim usually opens with a fast inspection and a scope from a template. The claim summary has a number on it. Then you read the list behind the number, and contractors report it comes up short in the places a template always leaves short.
Two arguments come up on roof scopes more often than most: the material grade the scope assumes, and the code items a like-for-like replacement leaves off. Both are answerable with documentation, and both start with reading the scope correctly.
ESXPress is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Allstate or any carrier. Xactimate is a registered trademark of Verisk. This is a workflow guide for the scope in front of you.
How Allstate scopes are built
An opening scope is assembled from a standard line roster for the loss type, priced against a price list edition, with a waste factor and a labor setting applied across the lines. On a replacement cost policy, the summary then splits the job into two numbers. Replacement cost value is what it costs to rebuild at today's prices. Actual cash value is that figure minus the depreciation the carrier withholds on the age and condition of what was there. The deductible comes off the top, and the summary usually prints what the claim pays if the withheld depreciation is later recovered.
Read in that order, the document stops being confusing. The scope is what the carrier agreed to build. Depreciation on those lines is held back until the work is done and invoiced. Anything the scope left out is not held back at all, which is why the scope itself is the thing to audit.
How to read an Allstate scope for gaps
Read the estimate against the code and your own measurements, not against the carrier's name. A first-pass scope comes up short in the same places whoever issues it, because the misses start in the process: a template roster, a measurement that gets rounded on the way in, and a scope written to close. The items below recur on first-pass roof scopes generally, and each is a line you can check on the document in front of you. For the carrier-specific picture, the carrier roof scope guide states plainly what we do and do not publish about a named carrier.
- Code upgrades. Ice and water barrier where the climate triggers it (IRC R905.2.7.1 in the 2018 editions, IRC R905.1.2 in the 2021 editions), and drip edge at the eaves and the rakes (IRC R905.2.8.5). A like-for-like scope replaces what was there and misses what the code now requires.
- Accessories. Starter course, ridge cap, pipe boots, step flashing, and counterflashing as their own lines.
- Detach and reset. Gutters, satellite dishes, and vents that come off and go back on for a re-roof.
- Waste and disposal. A dumpster and haul count that matches the layers and the access.
- Hidden decking. Documented at tear-off with photos and a sheet count.
The item-by-item version, with the code citations and the depreciation mechanics, is in the Allstate missing line items post.
Material grade and like-kind-and-quality disputes
Contractors report that the material-grade argument is where Allstate scopes draw the most disagreement. A scope can pay for a shingle that is the same general type but a different grade, thickness, or warranty tier than what was on the roof. Like kind and quality is the standard that decides whether the replacement actually matches the damaged material, and it turns on the product on the roof, not on a cheaper equivalent. The like kind and quality entry covers the standard. Document the existing product with photos and the manufacturer's label, and let the comparison do the arguing.
Documenting the code-upgrade argument
A code upgrade is the cleanest supplement line there is, because it rests on a citation, not on a preference. Say what the item is, cite the section that requires it, and cite the local adopted edition that puts that section in force. Ice and water barrier and drip edge are the two that come up most, and both have a specific code hook. Nothing about the argument needs adjectives. A reviewer can say yes to a citation, and there is no column on the form for emphasis. The format is covered in the code upgrade supplement entry.
A worked example: converting an Allstate PDF to ESX
Most Allstate scopes arrive as a PDF or a portal printout, which is easy to read and slow to compare. The move is to convert the scope PDF into an import-ready Xactimate ESX file, open it next to your own estimate, and read the two line by line. The comparison stops being an eyeball exercise. On dashboard conversions, the Completeness Advisor checks the converted scope against 93 rules covering construction, code, and supplemental items, and flags likely omissions with a citation for your review. It does not add anything to the estimate on its own. The PDF to Xactimate converter is where the workflow starts, and the supplement software overview covers the rest.
Ready to audit your next Allstate scope line by line? Start free. 5 conversions a month, no card required.
Review required: AI-assisted content requires professional review. Verify every line item, price, and total against your actual scope before submission.